Showing posts with label book to movie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label book to movie. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 7, 2013

Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters Book VS. Movie Review

Tuesday morning I checked Fandango and nearly flipped my lid when I realized there was going to be an early showing of Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters. I told my husband to forget whatever he had planned for the night: we were going to the movies.
 
And so we did. Because, based on the trailer, I could tell that they had done a much better job on this sequel than they did on the hugely disappointing Lightning Thief movie adaptation.

And they did. I'd be lying if I said they did not.

I fear that I can not say that they did much better. These movies continue to break my heart. The casting is absolutely perfect, the acting spans from pretty good to awesome, and the special effects work well. The glaring mistake that keeps chipping away at what I believe should be a runaway film franchise on par with Harry Potter is the missed opportunities for WORLD BUILDING.

The Wonderful World of the Percy Jackson Books and its Movies

If you have not read the Percy Jackson books, then you are missing out. Rick Riordan has brought Greek mythology to our modern world in the same way JK Rowling brought us magic. It lives within our world without us seeing it. Mere mortals are shrouded under what is called "the mist" so that we can not see the mythical creatures as they truly look, we cannot perceive the magic or superhuman feats that the half-boods or the gods may be performing right in front of us. However, just like in Harry Potter, they are happening all around us. Rick Riordan has built a world filed with characters, conflicts, and landmarks not only unique to his story, but that are also in ours. He brought Olympus, the Underworld and many other landmarks of the Greek myths to America and housed them within our cities, under our mountains and all of the other places that make so much sense once the mist is lifted from the reader's eyes. For me, half the fun of reading these books is learning where the gods are hiding among us. The other half of the fun is going on the quest with the heroes where they battle monsters, meet gods and, somewhere in between, struggle with many of the things ordinary kids do - growing up in single-parent homes, learning disabilities, being bullied in school, and feeling ashamed of a brother who is different are just a few.

For some reason these movies take all of that wonderfulness and come away with this: some heroes go on a quest where they meet a couple of gods and battle one or two monsters. That's it. The world is gone. The real-life problems that make these heroes relate-able are all but missing, those that are present are forced in uncomfortably leaving me screaming, "Show me, don't tell me!" There is no evidence in these movies that all of this is happening in our world, which, for me, is one of the coolest aspects of the story.

What Could Have Been

I walked out of the movie tonight heart-broken again, not because the movie was horrible, but because I know it was not good enough to sell books. It has been my opinion from the moment I read this series that it would take only one well-made Percy Jackson film to turn Percy Jackson into the next Harry Potter. I'm giving up on that now, and I've come up with a new theory: give up on the movies, this needs to be an epic TV show.

My Final Thoughts

Percy fans, go ahead and see this movie, but brace yourselves. I think you'll enjoy the casting, but you are going to feel rushed. For those of you who have not read Percy, I am curious to hear what you have to say about this movie - does it capture your interest? Does it maintain it?

In the end, I'm not sure if there will be a third film - I'm waiting for the box office numbers to determine that - but who knows? Maybe the third time will be the charm!

Have you read the Percy books?
 How were you introduced to the books?
 Have you seen Sea of Monsters? What did YOU think?


Friday, May 10, 2013

Book to Movie Review - The Great Gatsby (2013)


Jay Gatsby is not an ordinary man, he is, after all The Great Gatsby. Anyone who has read Fitzgerald's work knows that, but how does one portray this in a twenty-first century movie theater? How can one remain true to the era of the story (1920s) while building a story and character that can be just as magnanimous in 2013?

You call Baz Luhrmann.

I went to see The Great Gatsby last night and I loved it. Luhrmannn magically sets the scene with an aged, depressed and alcoholic Nick Caraway (Tobey Maguire's character) telling a doctor the story of a man who above all others embodied hope, Jay Gatsby. As he begins to reflect, Luhrmann presents the scene by embedding actual footage of the era into his introduction. By the time we are set free into Luhrmann's creative hands for the rest of the Gatsby ride, we are sold on setting, tone and emotion.

A surprise for me was how effectively the 3D was used in this film. My husband and I only went to the 3D showing because it was earliest one, but I must say the extra money was well worth it. Taking the trip with Nick to his first party at the Gatsby mansion in 3D was nothing short of awesome. It is a refreshing change to see a filmmaker use this technology to enhance their film, not just its ticket prices.

However, even if you skip the 3D, you still won't miss this film's greatest enhancement: the music. In my opinion Luhrmann has an amazing ability to add his soundtrack to the list of characters in his films. In Gatsby he delicately wove together classic sounds from the 1920s with cutting edge artists from today. This tapestry of tunes brought a vivacity to Gatsby's parties, heartbreak to love scenes and adventure Nick's journey in his brand new New York life. It is, without question, one of the major reasons this film will succeed with modern audiences.

In the end, this movie succeeds because of the strength of its story and characters. In Jay Gatsby we find a larger than life character who clings to hope in such an innocent way that he misses the obvious ugliness of his heart's desire and the world he inhabits. In Nick Calloway, we find a man balanced between two worlds of old and new money, with a foot in each door deciding which direction he wants to step. The actors become these men through their demeanor, their dress and their gait. These two, of course, are not alone. The entire cast delivers stellar performances driving the audience to love and hate them at all the right moments.

Book to Movie Review

As much as I enjoyed The Great Gatsby when I first read it this winter, I must (regretfully) admit that in some small way the story felt stale to me. Perhaps it was my own imagining of what the worlds of "old money" and "new money" are actually like in this era or any other. I don't think it was Fitzgerald's writing for any matter. The thing is, I read it and felt like that was definitely an "assigned reading" type of book that, perhaps, would come to life in a second reading (which I have been reluctant to do).

After emerging from the theater last night, I can see how hopelessly wrong I was! This is one of those cases where I will not say that "the book was better than the movie," nor will I say "the movie was better than the book," rather I will round this all up by saying this movie fully enhanced the reading of The Great Gatsby. So, in particular, if you have any kids moaning and groaning about this "Gatsby guy" they've been reading about in English class, I would highly recommend bringing them to the theater, just to give them a sense of the thrill within the pages.


My Final Word

I don't know what your plans are for this weekend, Old Sport, but if you are a book lover, a movie lover and you are looking to get transported to another time for a couple of hours, then you owe it to yourself to go see The Great Gatsby while it is on the big screen.


Tuesday, June 12, 2012

BOOK REVIEW - Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter by Seth Grahame-Smith


In preparation for the upcoming film and for the Word of the Nerd Book Club, I spent most of May reading Seth Grahame-Smith's Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter. I was new to both the author and this mash-up type of tale, so, unfortunately I am ill-equipped to offer a comparison in either of those arenas, however, I have a perspective to share with you nonetheless.

As a first time mash-up reader, I was thoroughly engaged by the very nature of the tale: a what if story about one of the giants in my history books. What if Abraham Lincoln was a vampire hunter? What if vampire control in America was the true motivation behind the Civil War? As a writer and a lifelong daydreamer, how could I not fall helplessly in love with a story that is hinged on such wild imaginings? Grahame-Smith's recreation of Lincoln's youth in order to create a man capable of carrying this secret horror all the way to the White House was just plain fun reading for me. Although, as I admitted in my weekly check-ins for the Word of the Nerd Book Club, History - American or otherwise - was never my strong suit in my studies in school, so in many respects I was along for the Grahame-Smith's literary ride from page one. The only thing I could ever be 100% sure of not being actual fact was any mentions of vampirism.

With all my weaknesses as a reviewer now revealed, let me plunge forth and tell you what I ultimately thought of the book. In a word, I'd describe the book as fun. I happen to enjoy vampire stories of all sorts and enjoy that every author has their own set of vampire "rules." I enjoy the weaving of these horrific beings into our society and unraveling how those with immortality could actually come to pull so many strings. I am also a sucker for the fight for justice and the idea that, in that, there can never truly be a black and white definition of what is right and what is wrong. For all these reasons I enjoyed Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter. And yet I stay my typing hand from punching out a word like "great" associated with this book, or that it is a "must-read."

For a little while I was perplexed by what was holding me back, but, as I was going over my weekly book club check-ins I was reminded of my discovery when I went to go see Dark Shadows on Mother's Day. Seth Grahame-Smith was the writer for that film. Big deal, you say. Who cares, Nicole?! I hear you. Here's the thing: I'm not out recommending Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter the novel to all of my reading friends because, to be honest, I can't imagine that this is a case where the book is going to be better than the movie. In fact, looking back on my reading experience, I wonder how early on in the development of the novel Grahame-Smith was already in movie-talk. Of course, I will be at the theater to see the movie as soon as it comes out, so I'll be back to let you know for sure, but right now this is my suspicion.

In short, if you are a fan of historical figures thrown into other-worldly circumstances, vampire lore and their affects on societies, or you just have to read the book before seeing the movie, then hurry up and go get your copy of Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter. It's a fun, quick read with all the ingredients for a blockbuster film: an emotionally fueled protagonist, epic and bloody battles, a fight to save the world (or at least a society) and an ending that hints at a lifetime of stories still untold. On the other hand, if you are "done" with vampires or would rather see the story reinterpreted for film, then this is one case where I will not barricade theater doors until you have proved you have finished your reading assignment!

To see the latest trailer for the movie Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter, check out Natasha Collier's post.


Friday, March 23, 2012

The Hunger Games: Book VS. Movie [Review]

It's just before 3am here on the east coast and I'm back home from The Hunger Games movie's midnight showing. I am overjoyed to let you know that I thought it was amazing.

My Preconceptions of the Film 
 
I went to this movie excited, but guarded. I worried about how a PG-13 rating might diminish the ominous threat posed by the Capitol and their games. I wondered if the absence of characters like Madge (the mayor's daughter who gives Katniss Everdeen her mockingjay pin in the book) would pull apart themes in the story before it even truly began. I was sure that this book, written in first person, would get lost in translation as it was adapted for the screen. As I sat in the theater filled with squealing teenagers ogling over Peeta Mellark and his every romantic gesture, I realized that all of my worries were unnecessary.

I may not have told you this before, but I do not work in the film industry. While I tend to have creative outbursts from time to time, I was reminded tonight that I lack the scope and the vision to have fully imagined how true professionals in the field could bring this book to life on the screen maintaining its tone, its themes and its unique setting of the world of Panem. 

First Person Perspective Versus Third Person Omniscient 

The most powerful tool used in the film adaptation of this book to movie was the cutting of the strings of our first person perspective. In Suzanne Collins' novel we are taken through the story of the Hunger Games through the eyes of our protagonist, Katniss Everdeen. This makes for an emotionally charged and intimate story. The reader feels connected to Katniss, they understand her motivations and they root for her through and through. The one weakness in it, however, (which is present in all first person tales) is that we are limited in our understanding of Katniss's world since we know it only as she does. While we are privy to her internal monologues and feelings on all things happening to her, we still may not know why such things are occurring.

The Hunger Games movie did an amazing job of taking us "behind the scenes." For the first time we are able to see plots and plans made by the Gamemakers, by President Snow and even witness reactions to the Games in one of the Districts. Although these are all things that Katniss eventually learns about in The Hunger Games series, to see them happening in real time helps bring the dystopian world of Panem to life.

How PG-13 and the Violence Were Maintained
 
As far as my worry over the PG-13 rating of this film, I, again, must give credit to the creative thinkers behind the film for showing me how one can portray violence without great gory offense. When the rating for the film was initially announcd, I declared that the story was doomed - How could a story with teens violently killing teens get a PG-13 rating?! I imagined they would be glossing over the violence and, in turn, be glossing over the very nature of the Hunger Games. So here's the trick I observed - when a violent scene approached and was needed, the cinematography itself seemed to shift.

It felt as if the camera was unsteady, shaky, perhaps one could even describe it as dizzying. Horrible things were happening on the screen, but as the camera jerked this way and that, we only saw bits and pieces of the act. This sounds like it may be annoying to watch, but what I found was that it was unsettling and I can't imagine a better feeling to have in the presence of horrific violence. So, with a little creative twist, the appropriate mood was struck, the audience was more than aware of the violent act and the rating for the target audience was maintained. Brilliant.

Character and Setting Design
 
My final commentary is reserved for the overall look of the people and places in the film. As I watched the trailers getting ready for the film's release, I was taken aback by the stark looking Capitol that kept flashing before my eyes, I thought the children of district 12 looked too uniform and I wasn't sure about the brief glimpses of the Capitol citizens I saw. Silly, silly me to make such rash judgements on snippets!

Within the full context of the movie, there was nothing "uniform" about District 12 citizens except that their clothing all looks drab - in the book this is alluded to due to the nature of their industry, coal mining. As for the my impression of a "stark" Capitol, this is simply a reflection of the very modern, sleek design of all that is there; most of the details which add a unique flair and personality to the place were left out of the trailers. The most magnificent Capitol detail of all, however, was its citizens. Collins writes of a population obsessed with personal appearance and enhancements through make-up, surgery, tattoos, fantastic hair designs and loud, garish style, but I was unsure this description could be appropriately presented on the screen. The people of the Capitol were just the right kind of eye-catching - I wanted to see their every detail, but when I would look closely, their unnaturalness would turn from fantastic to disturbing.

Final Comments
 
As I assess this movie from the perspective of a reader of The Hunger Games books, I am happy to report that this movie adaptation is one I think readers will be happy to come home from. Madge is not the only character missing and, yes, there are a couple of changes here and there made either due to time limitations or story flow that may initially sting. However, by movie's end I will be surprised if my fellow readers don't leave this film feeling satisfied.

Hunger Games fans, this time the odds were ever in our favor - go get your friends, get your tickets and enjoy!

Have you seen it yet? 
What are your impressions of the movie?
Have you read the books yet?





***FOR HUNGER GAMES FANS: TEEFURY IS FEATURING A HUNGER GAMES THEMED T-SHIRT ALL DAY ON MARCH 23, 2012***
TeeFury.com
REMEMBER YOU HAVE UNTIL MIDNIGHT EST TO GET THIS $10 T-SHIRT BEFORE IT GOES AWAY FOREVER!